Lived Experience – refers to the type of knowledge one has about the world as a result of experiencing the world in their own specific way
Values – attitudes we have that determine the way we act and choices we make
Anthropologists utilize what we call a phenomenological perspective to study people, which means they aim to understand the unique and particular lived experience of others. This lived experience includes how the body and the senses work together to interact with the world – what we call an embodied experience. It also includes ideas, thoughts, views, and personal histories, which for each person and culture are different.
When we talk about objective versus subjective experiences of the world, it means that instead of seeing the world as if we all see it the same way, to see it from the unique perspective of one person, and realize that the world is different for all of us based on our experiences of it. Understanding the way other people subjectively experience the world allows us to widen our own perspectives and understand each other better.
Can we ever really understand what it feels like to be another person? Is it possible to really walk in someone else’s shoes? Or will we always see other people as a result of who we are ourselves? These are questions not only anthropologists ask, but ones we must also ask ourselves if we want to understand someone else’s personal experience of the world, and how it is different from our own.
||| Explore the Literature |||
Saleh, Zainab. Return to Ruin: Iraqi Narrative of Exile and Nostalgia. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
Summary from publisher. With the U.S. invasion of Iraq, Iraqis abroad, hoping to return one day to a better Iraq, became uncertain exiles. Return to Ruin tells the human story of this exile in the context of decades of U.S. imperial interests in Iraq—from the U.S. backing of the 1963 Ba’th coup and support of Saddam Hussein’s regime in the 1980s, to the 1991 Gulf War and 2003 invasion and occupation. Zainab Saleh shares the experiences of Iraqis she met over fourteen years of fieldwork in Iraqi London—offering stories from an aging communist nostalgic for the streets she marched since childhood, a devout Shi’i dreaming of holy cities and family graves, and newly uprooted immigrants with fresh memories of loss, as well as her own. Focusing on debates among Iraqi exiles about what it means to be an Iraqi after years of displacement, Saleh weaves a narrative that draws attention to a once-dominant, vibrant Iraqi cultural landscape and social and political shifts among the diaspora after decades of authoritarianism, war, and occupation in Iraq. Through it all, this book illuminates how Iraqis continue to fashion a sense of belonging and imagine a future, built on the shards of these shattered memories.
Graeber, David. 2001. Towards the anthropology of value: The false coin of our dreams. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Summary from publisher: Now a widely cited classic, this innovative book is the first comprehensive synthesis of economic, political, and cultural theories of value. David Graeber reexamines a century of anthropological thought about value and exchange, in large measure to find a way out of ongoing quandaries in current social theory, which have become critical at the present moment of ideological collapse in the face of Neoliberalism. Rooted in an engaged, dynamic realism, Graeber argues that projects of cultural comparison are in a sense necessarily revolutionary projects: He attempts to synthesize the best insights of Karl Marx and Marcel Mauss, arguing that these figures represent two extreme, but ultimately complementary, possibilities in the shape such a project might take. Graeber breathes new life into the classic anthropological texts on exchange, value, and economy. He rethinks the cases of Iroquois wampum, Pacific kula exchanges, and the Kwakiutl potlatch within the flow of world historical processes, and recasts value as a model of human meaning-making, which far exceeds rationalist/reductive economist paradigms.
Cyril S. Belshaw. 1956. The Identification of Values in Anthropology. American Journal of Sociology, 64:6, 555-562.
Abstract: The paper examines the connotations of the term “value” as it has influenced recent anthropological thought. Current usage, leaning heavily on ethics and world view, is concerned with ideas and orientations rather than with action. Anthropological usage, unlike the sociological or philosophical, has ignored the approach of economics, which is concerned with values revealed in action. A system of values cannot be described empirically without assumptions about the presence or absence of values. An ideal scheme is presented, showing the steps necessary to identify values and the difficulties of this as an empirical procedure.
Heintz, Monica The Anthropology of Moralities. New York/Oxford: Berghahn Press.
Summary from publisher: Anthropologists have been keenly aware of the tension between cultural relativism and absolute norms, and nowhere has this been more acute than with regards to moral values. Can we study the Other’s morality without applying our own normative judgments? How do social anthropologists keep both the distance required by science and the empathy required for the analysis of lived experiences? The plurality of moralities has not received an explicit and focused attention until recently, when accelerated globalization often resulted in the collision of different value systems. Observing, describing and assessing values cross-culturally, the authors propose various methodological approaches to the study of moralities, illustrated with rich ethnographic accounts, thus offering a valuable guide for students of anthropology, sociology and cultural studies and for professionals concerned with the empirical and cross-cultural study of values.
Csordas, Thomas, editor. 1994. Embodiment and Experience The Existential Ground of Culture and Self. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Summary from publisher: Students of culture have been increasingly concerned with the ways in which cultural values are “inscribed” on the body. These essays go beyond this passive construal of the body to a position in which embodiment is understood as the existential condition of cultural life. From this standpoint embodiment is reducible neither to representations of the body, to the body as an objectification of power, to the body as a physical entity or biological organism, nor to the body as an inalienable centre of individual consciousness. This more sensate and dynamic view is applied by the contributors to a variety of topics, including the expression of emotion, the experience of pain, ritual healing, dietary customs, and political violence. Their purpose is to contribute to a phenomenological theory of culture and self–an anthropology that is not merely about the body, but from the body.